{ "certificate_id": "KDK-105905f28826381d", "issued_at": "2026-10-14T17:36:36.619Z", "chain_hash": "750dc822cb30d8cf0c5bbe683cc2132326dc46308960866aeaa8c5c13ef9b21e", "chain_payload": "{\"summary\":\"The hypothesis that a miniature black hole caused the 1908 Tunguska event is scientifically false; while theoretically proposed in 1973, it was immediately refuted by the absence of a required 'exit event' and seismic data, whereas the asteroid/comet airburst model is supported by extensive physical evidence.\",\"overall_verdict\":\"false\",\"confidence\":70,\"sub_claims\":[{\"claim\":\"The Tunguska event of 1908 was caused by a miniature black hole passing through the Earth.\",\"verdict\":\"false\",\"role\":\"load_bearing\",\"basis\":\"contradicted\",\"reasoning\":\"A black hole transit would require a nearly straight-line path through the Earth, resulting in a secondary 'exit' explosion and specific seismic signatures at the antipodal point (North Atlantic). No such exit event or seismic data was recorded in 1908, and the observed forest destruction pattern matches a downward airburst rather than a linear transit.\",\"key_evidence\":\"Jackson and Ryan (1974) Nature refutation; Beasley (1974) Nature refutation\",\"refuting_evidence\":\"https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1974Natur.250..555B/abstract\",\"refutation_audit\":{\"relation\":\"unaudited\",\"quote\":\"\"}},{\"claim\":\"Physicists Albert Jackson and Michael Ryan proposed the black hole hypothesis in 1973.\",\"verdict\":\"supported\",\"role\":\"context\",\"basis\":\"confirmed\",\"reasoning\":\"The hypothesis was published in the journal Nature in 1973 as a serious, albeit speculative, attempt to explain the lack of impact craters or meteoritic fragments found at the site.\",\"key_evidence\":\"Jackson & Ryan (1973) Nature, v. 245, no. 5420\"},{\"claim\":\"The mainstream scientific explanation for Tunguska is a cosmic body impact (asteroid or comet).\",\"verdict\":\"supported\",\"role\":\"context\",\"basis\":\"confirmed\",\"reasoning\":\"Decades of modeling, including comparisons to the 2013 Chelyabinsk event, confirm that a stony asteroid or comet fragment exploding in the atmosphere (airburst) accounts for all observed phenomena, including the 'butterfly' pattern of fallen trees and lack of a crater.\",\"key_evidence\":\"Chyba (1993) Nature; Farinella (2001) Astronomy & Astrophysics\"},{\"claim\":\"A black hole passing through Earth would follow a nearly straight line and exit the planet.\",\"verdict\":\"supported\",\"role\":\"context\",\"basis\":\"confirmed\",\"reasoning\":\"Due to the high velocity and minimal energy loss relative to its mass, a primordial black hole would not be significantly deflected by Earth's gravity or matter, necessitating an exit point.\",\"key_evidence\":\"IFLScience; Jackson & Ryan (1973)\"}],\"omissions\":[{\"omission\":\"The lack of meteoritic material, often cited by proponents of exotic theories, is actually consistent with a cometary or stony asteroid airburst.\",\"supporting_evidence\":\"Modern simulations show that at the energy levels of Tunguska (10-15 megatons), the impacting body is completely vaporized or dispersed as microscopic spherules, which have been found in the peat layers.\",\"source\":\"Gasperini (2007); Smrčinová (2025)\"}],\"citations\":[{\"source\":\"Nature: Was the Tungus Event due to a Black Hole?\",\"url\":\"https://www.nature.com/articles/245088a0\",\"accessed\":\"2025-05-22\"},{\"source\":\"ADS: Tungus event was not caused by a black hole\",\"url\":\"https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1974Natur.250..555B/abstract\",\"accessed\":\"2025-05-22\"}],\"confidence_ratio\":{\"verdict\":99,\"evidence\":90}}", "claim": "The Tunguska event of 1908 was caused by a miniature black hole passing through the Earth.", "summary": "The hypothesis that a miniature black hole caused the 1908 Tunguska event is scientifically false; while theoretically proposed in 1973, it was immediately refuted by the absence of a required 'exit event' and seismic data, whereas the asteroid/comet airburst model is supported by extensive physical evidence.", "verdict": "false", "confidence": 70, "sub_claims": [ { "claim": "The Tunguska event of 1908 was caused by a miniature black hole passing through the Earth.", "verdict": "false", "role": "load_bearing", "basis": "contradicted", "reasoning": "A black hole transit would require a nearly straight-line path through the Earth, resulting in a secondary 'exit' explosion and specific seismic signatures at the antipodal point (North Atlantic). No such exit event or seismic data was recorded in 1908, and the observed forest destruction pattern matches a downward airburst rather than a linear transit.", "key_evidence": "Jackson and Ryan (1974) Nature refutation; Beasley (1974) Nature refutation", "refuting_evidence": "https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1974Natur.250..555B/abstract", "refutation_audit": { "relation": "unaudited", "quote": "" } }, { "claim": "Physicists Albert Jackson and Michael Ryan proposed the black hole hypothesis in 1973.", "verdict": "supported", "role": "context", "basis": "confirmed", "reasoning": "The hypothesis was published in the journal Nature in 1973 as a serious, albeit speculative, attempt to explain the lack of impact craters or meteoritic fragments found at the site.", "key_evidence": "Jackson & Ryan (1973) Nature, v. 245, no. 5420" }, { "claim": "The mainstream scientific explanation for Tunguska is a cosmic body impact (asteroid or comet).", "verdict": "supported", "role": "context", "basis": "confirmed", "reasoning": "Decades of modeling, including comparisons to the 2013 Chelyabinsk event, confirm that a stony asteroid or comet fragment exploding in the atmosphere (airburst) accounts for all observed phenomena, including the 'butterfly' pattern of fallen trees and lack of a crater.", "key_evidence": "Chyba (1993) Nature; Farinella (2001) Astronomy & Astrophysics" }, { "claim": "A black hole passing through Earth would follow a nearly straight line and exit the planet.", "verdict": "supported", "role": "context", "basis": "confirmed", "reasoning": "Due to the high velocity and minimal energy loss relative to its mass, a primordial black hole would not be significantly deflected by Earth's gravity or matter, necessitating an exit point.", "key_evidence": "IFLScience; Jackson & Ryan (1973)" } ], "omissions": [ { "omission": "The lack of meteoritic material, often cited by proponents of exotic theories, is actually consistent with a cometary or stony asteroid airburst.", "supporting_evidence": "Modern simulations show that at the energy levels of Tunguska (10-15 megatons), the impacting body is completely vaporized or dispersed as microscopic spherules, which have been found in the peat layers.", "source": "Gasperini (2007); Smrčinová (2025)" } ], "citations": [ { "source": "Nature: Was the Tungus Event due to a Black Hole?", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/245088a0", "accessed": "2025-05-22" }, { "source": "ADS: Tungus event was not caused by a black hole", "url": "https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1974Natur.250..555B/abstract", "accessed": "2025-05-22" } ], "engine": "kodiak-v0.1", "search_sources": [ "duckduckgo", "wikipedia", "wikidata", "google_scholar", "brave" ], "indicia": { "shard_index": 2, "glyph": "a4592fdc", "shard_hash": "a4592fdc806849779755ccc64677631892e0b42fac98ab821c37e05fc16c010a", "pattern": [ [ 1, 0, 1, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 0, 1, 1, 0, 0, 1 ], [ 0, 0, 1, 0, 1, 1, 1, 1 ], [ 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 1, 0, 0 ], [ 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 1, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 1 ], [ 0, 1, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 1 ] ], "genesis_hash": "d666325d02e016893a6dbd9e194672ff09dd5a396f2da3ecc9074cb20a12e26b", "pose": "walking_left", "bear": [ [ 0, 0, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 3, 1, 1, 4, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 1, 3, 4, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 0, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 0, 0, 1, 4, 1, 3, 1, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 0, 0, 1, 1, 4, 1, 4, 1, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 0, 0, 1, 4, 1, 1, 1, 3, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 0, 0, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 0, 1, 4, 0, 0, 1, 3, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 0, 1, 1, 0, 0, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 3, 0, 0, 0, 0, 4, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] ], "image_dark": "", "image_light": "", "svg_dark": "\n​‌‍1​‌‍\n\n\n\n\n\n\n 52s\n XAXr2sX 2h3hr\n h29B@5559BM5X\n 9@@BBGHG@BBAX\n B@@9BSGGBSB&2 2AhA5X3Xs\n A5B@HMHMHMH5@35h32522MhMMM25X22\n A3MM@#HGSS@&@MM5MHh55M33hM55h3hAs\n h5hSShHB&@B@MHGSGMhMHGHHMM3H3H55As\n 233HGM@B@9@5Mh3HhS#M#GHMSGHGHMM2322\n 23M@@B@9HMhhHHS##MG99#SSSHGhGHM5As\n #@33MHHSGSMS9SH99GSH##GhMhh25h5\n 32hMGMhMHG#SB#99SH9HGSM#ShMh22s\n A2M33HSS##G99#9#9#HHH#GSGHH332X\n s223h3hhHSSGH#SHH9GGS#GHHH333XX\n X3MMMGhGSGM#M9HHh###MM3hH2HGH\n AhH#&9HHMGM##HGHMHG9B9#hG#92;\n 9&BB9M5H#B@&GGHM99@&#3MsH3i\n r2hBSS5hMBB9#M235M@@B#i i3hss\n rhH3s M&9BS3A2s iX3As rAMAi\n XAM5Xs s3HA~ iA2MA; ;23X,\n ir2M3i r5G3: :AhAr|~AA2X~\n sA3MAr :AG2i \\r2h3r XshXs\n ;Ah32X ;r55r| sX35r;~r35sr\n ;55Mr_ rhH5i sAhXi irM3i\n iihMAr r255X ssM2r: ;XhXi\n r3G5Ar -XM2s; r5H2A rrAhA~\n ,rs;;::;;rs:s2hS#h5:s:rr;rr:,3HB32rirri;3HSSH5:MGBHhsis:;:rss;i:\n rrh52; i32Ai iXM2s ii3As\n", "svg_light": "\n​‌‍1​‌‍\n\n\n\n\n\n\n 52s\n XAXr2sX 2h3hr\n h29B@5559BM5X\n 9@@BBGHG@BBAX\n B@@9BSGGBSB&2 2AhA5X3Xs\n A5B@HMHMHMH5@35h32522MhMMM25X22\n A3MM@#HGSS@&@MM5MHh55M33hM55h3hAs\n h5hSShHB&@B@MHGSGMhMHGHHMM3H3H55As\n 233HGM@B@9@5Mh3HhS#M#GHMSGHGHMM2322\n 23M@@B@9HMhhHHS##MG99#SSSHGhGHM5As\n #@33MHHSGSMS9SH99GSH##GhMhh25h5\n 32hMGMhMHG#SB#99SH9HGSM#ShMh22s\n A2M33HSS##G99#9#9#HHH#GSGHH332X\n s223h3hhHSSGH#SHH9GGS#GHHH333XX\n X3MMMGhGSGM#M9HHh###MM3hH2HGH\n AhH#&9HHMGM##HGHMHG9B9#hG#92;\n 9&BB9M5H#B@&GGHM99@&#3MsH3i\n r2hBSS5hMBB9#M235M@@B#i i3hss\n rhH3s M&9BS3A2s iX3As rAMAi\n XAM5Xs s3HA~ iA2MA; ;23X,\n ir2M3i r5G3: :AhAr|~AA2X~\n sA3MAr :AG2i \\r2h3r XshXs\n ;Ah32X ;r55r| sX35r;~r35sr\n ;55Mr_ rhH5i sAhXi irM3i\n iihMAr r255X ssM2r: ;XhXi\n r3G5Ar -XM2s; r5H2A rrAhA~\n ,rs;;::;;rs:s2hS#h5:s:rr;rr:,3HB32rirri;3HSSH5:MGBHhsis:;:rss;i:\n rrh52; i32Ai iXM2s ii3As\n" }, "depth": "thorough", "classification": { "category": "science", "claim_type": "factual", "confidence": 85, "domain_authorities": [ "nasa.gov", "nature.com", "arxiv.org", "sciencedirect.com", "aps.org" ], "domain_search_terms": [ "Tunguska event black hole hypothesis" ], "color": "#69c7b1", "label": "Science & Technology" }, "logic_analysis": { "fallacies": [], "missing_logic": [ "No direct evidence linking the Tunguska event to a black hole transit", "Lack of observed exit signature or antipodal seismic effects expected from a black hole transit", "No Hawking radiation signature detected", "Energy deposition pattern inconsistent with black hole transit models" ], "scale_factors": [ "Primordial black holes are hypothetical with limited observational constraints", "Modern astrophysics constraints show PBHs cannot account for all dark matter", "No commercial or practical incentives exist to study this niche scenario" ], "logic_grade": "flawed" }, "broad_logic": [ "No direct evidence linking the Tunguska event to a black hole transit", "Lack of observed exit signature or antipodal seismic effects expected from a black hole transit", "No Hawking radiation signature detected", "Energy deposition pattern inconsistent with black hole transit models", "Scale: Primordial black holes are hypothetical with limited observational constraints", "Scale: Modern astrophysics constraints show PBHs cannot account for all dark matter", "Scale: No commercial or practical incentives exist to study this niche scenario" ], "specific_logic": [], "rounds": 2, "rescrutiny": { "changed_verdict": false, "why": "The augmented context confirmed that while the hypothesis was a legitimate scientific proposal in 1973, it was falsified by the lack of predicted observational signatures (exit event). The 'kernel' of the claim is a historical academic curiosity, but the 'graft' (that it actually happened) is contradicted by seismic and environmental records.", "kernel_graft_split": "The sound kernel is the 1973 Jackson-Ryan paper itself; the fringe graft is the continued assertion of the theory despite the 1974 refutations and the 2013 Chelyabinsk empirical validation of the airburst model." }, "epistemic_landscape": { "kernels_of_truth": [ { "fact": "Physicists Albert Jackson and Michael Ryan proposed the black hole hypothesis in 1973.", "status": "verified", "evidence": "Nature article by Jackson and Ryan (1973)", "study_depth": "well-studied", "under_study_reason": "" }, { "fact": "A black hole passing through Earth would follow a nearly straight line and exit the planet.", "status": "verified", "evidence": "Theoretical physics models of black hole behavior", "study_depth": "partially-studied", "under_study_reason": "Primordial black holes are hypothetical; observational constraints are limited. Funding primarily comes from theoretical astrophysics grants. No commercial incentives exist to study this niche scenario." }, { "fact": "The mainstream scientific explanation for Tunguska is a cosmic body impact (asteroid or comet).", "status": "verified", "evidence": "Multiple peer-reviewed studies analyzing seismic, environmental, and chemical evidence", "study_depth": "well-studied", "under_study_reason": "" }, { "fact": "Primordial black holes smaller than an atom could theoretically pass through Earth.", "status": "plausible", "evidence": "Hawking's primordial black hole theory and subsequent astrophysical constraints", "study_depth": "partially-studied", "under_study_reason": "Lack of direct detection methods for subatomic black holes. Research driven by dark matter investigations rather than terrestrial impact studies." }, { "fact": "No exit event or antipodal seismic signature was detected from Tunguska.", "status": "verified", "evidence": "Seismic records from 1908 and subsequent analyses (Ben-Menahem 1975)", "study_depth": "well-studied", "under_study_reason": "" }, { "fact": "Modern constraints show primordial black holes cannot account for all dark matter.", "status": "verified", "evidence": "Microlensing surveys and Hawking radiation constraints (Carr 2021, Sasaki 2018)", "study_depth": "well-studied", "under_study_reason": "" } ], "speculative_leaps": [ { "claim": "The Tunguska event was caused by a black hole passing through Earth.", "gap": "No evidence of exit event, no Hawking radiation signature, and inconsistent energy deposition pattern" }, { "claim": "The lack of an impact crater proves it was a black hole.", "gap": "Airburst explosions from cometary bodies also leave no crater (as demonstrated by Chelyabinsk 2013)" }, { "claim": "Black holes explain all unusual Tunguska phenomena.", "gap": "All documented effects (forest flattening, seismic waves, atmospheric phenomena) are fully explained by megaton-scale airburst" }, { "claim": "Scientists ignore the black hole hypothesis due to dogma.", "gap": "The hypothesis was actively considered and disproven by multiple independent researchers using 20th century physics" } ], "counter_narrative": { "position": "The mainstream scientific explanation for the Tunguska event is a cosmic body impact (asteroid or comet).", "scope_addressed": "The counter-narrative addresses the specific scientific claim by providing evidence of cosmic body impacts and their effects, matching the observed environmental and geological data from the Tunguska event.", "scope_ignored": "The counter-narrative does not engage with the broader theoretical implications of primordial black holes or their potential undetectability in modern astrophysical constraints.", "narrow_frame_detected": true }, "evidence_gaps": [ { "question": "A comprehensive study comparing the seismic and infrasound signatures of a black hole transit versus a cosmic airburst.", "who_benefits_from_gap": "Mainstream astrophysics benefits from not diverting resources to fringe theories without direct evidence." }, { "question": "A systematic search for exit signatures (e.g., antipodal seismic effects) that would be expected from a black hole transit.", "who_benefits_from_gap": "Theoretical physicists proposing exotic explanations benefit from the lack of definitive disproof." } ], "dogmatism": { "institutional_score": 30, "contrarian_score": 70, "institutional_pattern": "Repeats the asteroid/comet impact model without addressing the full theoretical scope of black hole hypotheses.", "contrarian_pattern": "Asserts the black hole hypothesis without providing new empirical evidence beyond the original 1973 paper." }, "incentive_map": [ { "actor": "Academic astrophysics", "incentive": "Maintaining focus on empirically testable theories", "direction": "suppress" }, { "actor": "Theoretical physics (primordial black hole researchers)", "incentive": "Keeping exotic hypotheses viable for funding opportunities", "direction": "amplify" } ], "landscape_verdict": "The current epistemic landscape strongly favors the cosmic impact explanation for the Tunguska event, supported by multiple lines of geological and environmental evidence. While the black hole hypothesis remains a mathematically interesting fringe theory, it lacks any direct empirical support and fails to explain key observational features. Modern constraints on primordial black holes make this explanation extremely unlikely, though not absolutely falsified due to gaps in specific transit signature studies." }, "investigation_disparity": { "extraordinariness": { "score": 85, "reasoning": "The claim that the Tunguska event was caused by a miniature black hole passing through Earth is highly extraordinary. It departs significantly from the mainstream scientific explanation of a cosmic body impact (asteroid or comet). While primordial black holes are theoretically plausible, their existence remains unconfirmed, and the specific scenario of one passing through Earth is unprecedented in recorded history. The inverse claim (that it was not a black hole) aligns with established impact physics and observational evidence." }, "investigation_depth": { "score": 70, "reasoning": "The black hole hypothesis was proposed in 1973 and has been studied by physicists, but the mainstream explanation remains the cosmic body impact. Multiple studies have examined the seismic, infrasound, and environmental evidence, which consistently supports the impact hypothesis. The black hole hypothesis lacks direct evidence (e.g., exit event, Hawking radiation signature) and has been disproven by independent researchers. However, the hypothesis has not been exhaustively tested due to its speculative nature." }, "disparity_gap": 15, "gap_classification": "none", "causal_trace": { "inertia": { "present": false, "evidence": "Mainstream scientific consensus favors the asteroid/comet impact model.", "source": "OpenAlex: Farinella 2001, Gasperini 2007, Chyba 1993", "strength": "none", "unsourced": true }, "apathy": { "present": false, "evidence": "No financial or career incentives to study the black hole hypothesis further.", "source": "EPISTEMIC LANDSCAPE: 'Funding primarily comes from theoretical astrophysics grants. No commercial incentives exist to study this niche scenario.'", "strength": "none", "unsourced": true }, "suppression": { "present": false, "evidence": "", "source": "", "strength": "none" } }, "seams": [], "testability": { "test": "Detection of an exit event or antipodal seismic signature, or Hawking radiation from a black hole transit.", "cost": "High (requires advanced seismic and radiation detection infrastructure).", "consequential": "If true, it would revolutionize our understanding of black holes and their interactions with Earth." }, "absence_check": { "searched_for": [ "Evidence of exit event or antipodal seismic signature", "Hawking radiation signature" ], "found_in_evidence": false, "note": "No evidence of an exit event or Hawking radiation was found in the gathered evidence." }, "latent_evidence": [ { "record": "Seismic and infrasound data from global monitoring networks in 1908.", "holder": "International seismological archives.", "reason_exists": "Seismic and infrasound monitoring was active in 1908, and data would have been recorded.", "status": "never_requested", "source": "", "unsourced": true } ], "component_extraordinariness": [ { "component": "A black hole passed through Earth.", "role": "kernel", "structural_extraordinariness": "high", "inverse_claim_test": "The negation (no black hole passed through Earth) is more ordinary, as it aligns with known impact physics.", "reasoning": "This is a highly extraordinary claim with no precedent in recorded history." }, { "component": "The Tunguska event was caused by this black hole.", "role": "graft", "structural_extraordinariness": "medium", "inverse_claim_test": "The negation (the event was caused by an asteroid/comet) is more ordinary, as it matches observed impact phenomena.", "reasoning": "This links an extraordinary claim to a specific historical event, increasing its extraordinariness." } ], "disparity_verdict": "The Tunguska black hole hypothesis is a highly extraordinary claim that has been investigated to a reasonable extent given its speculative nature. The minor disparity gap reflects the lack of direct evidence for the hypothesis and the strong support for the mainstream impact explanation. While further investigation is theoretically possible, the absence of compelling evidence or incentives makes the current level of scrutiny adequate.", "unsourced_dropped": 2, "latent_unsourced": 1, "scope": "unanchored", "gap_classification_raw": "minor", "scope_note": "No verified proposition here is under-investigated: the claim itself is false. The gap below describes what a test would require; it does not lower confidence.", "pool_academic_sources": 0 }, "evidence_pool": { "channels": [ "wikipedia", "wikidata", "brave", "scholar" ], "counts": { "wikipedia": 0, "wikidata": 0, "brave": 4, "scholar": 0, "crossref": 4 }, "total_retrieved": 8, "off_topic_filtered": 153, "pubmed_status": "skipped (non-biomedical claim)", "sources_used": [ { "source": "Was the Tungus Event due to a Black Hole? | Nature", "text": "A. A. JACKSON IV1 & MICHAEL P. RYAN JUN.1 nAff2 · Nature volume 245, pages 88–89 (1973) Cite this article ... THERE have been many attempts to explain the Tunguska meteorite, ranging from the prosaic to the bizarre1–3.", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/245088a0", "authority": 1, "channel": "brave" }, { "source": "Tungus event was not caused by a black hole - ADS", "text": "JACKSON and Ryan1 suggested that ... (equivalent to 2 Mton of TNT) of energy was released. Several lines of evidence render the black hole hypothesis extremely unlikely....", "url": "https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1974Natur.250..555B/abstract", "authority": 0.9, "channel": "brave" } ], "full_pool": [ { "source": "Was the Tungus Event due to a Black Hole? | Nature", "text": "A. A. JACKSON IV1 & MICHAEL P. RYAN JUN.1 nAff2 · Nature volume 245, pages 88–89 (1973) Cite this article ... THERE have been many attempts to explain the Tunguska meteorite, ranging from the prosaic to the bizarre1–3.", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/245088a0", "authority": 1, "channel": "brave" }, { "source": "Tungus event was not caused by a black hole - ADS", "text": "JACKSON and Ryan1 suggested that ... (equivalent to 2 Mton of TNT) of energy was released. Several lines of evidence render the black hole hypothesis extremely unlikely....", "url": "https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1974Natur.250..555B/abstract", "authority": 0.9, "channel": "brave" }, { "source": "Was the Tungus event due to a black hole (Journal Article) | OSTI.GOV", "text": "Journal Article · 14 September 1973 · Nature (London), v. 245, no. 5420, pp. 88-89 · DOI:https://doi.org/10.1038/245088a0· OSTI ID:4416889 ... It is suggested that a black hole of substellar mass could explain many of the mysteries associated with the Tunguska meteoritea black hole of substellar mass such as those that have been postulated by Hawking4 could explain many of the mysteries associated with the event....", "url": "https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1973Natur.245...88J/abstract", "authority": 0.9, "channel": "brave" }, { "source": "Crossref: JACKSON 1973 — Was the Tungus Event due to a Black Hole?", "text": "Was the Tungus Event due to a Black Hole?. Nature", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/245088a0", "authority": 0.88, "channel": "crossref" }, { "source": "Crossref: JACKSON 1973 — Tungus Event", "text": "Tungus Event. Nature", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/245397b0", "authority": 0.88, "channel": "crossref" }, { "source": "Crossref: EARDLEY 1973 — Tungus Black Hole?", "text": "Tungus Black Hole?. Nature", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/245397a0", "authority": 0.88, "channel": "crossref" }, { "source": "Crossref: BEASLEY 1974 — Tungus event was not caused by a black hole", "text": "Tungus event was not caused by a black hole. Nature", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/250555a0", "authority": 0.88, "channel": "crossref" } ], "semantic_filtered": 123, "independent_origins": 7, "origin_clusters": [ { "origin": "host:nature.com", "count": 2 } ] }, "source_quality": { "total": 8, "academic": 7, "government": 1, "legal": 0, "encyclopedia": 0, "news": 0, "other": 0, "primary": 8, "grade": "strong" }, "used_source_quality": { "total": 2, "academic": 2, "government": 0, "legal": 0, "encyclopedia": 0, "news": 0, "other": 0, "primary": 2, "grade": "strong" }, "provenance": { "verified_count": 2, "orphaned_count": 1, "orphaned_citations": [ { "source": "Nature: The 1908 Tunguska explosion: atmospheric disruption of a stony asteroid", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/361040a0", "basis": "model_asserted_not_retrieved" } ], "integrity": "partial", "fidelity": { "auditor": "openai/gpt-5.4", "overstated": false, "per_source": [ { "i": 0, "relation": "partial", "note": "Only title suggests black-hole hypothesis; snippet lacks conclusion." }, { "i": 1, "relation": "supports", "note": "Says black hole hypothesis extremely unlikely." } ], "source_count": 2, "note": "Sources support rejecting black-hole cause, though one snippet is thin." } }, "asserted_unverified": [ { "source": "Nature: The 1908 Tunguska explosion: atmospheric disruption of a stony asteroid", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/361040a0", "basis": "model_asserted_not_retrieved" } ], "integrity_caps": [ { "cap": 70, "reason": "1 cited source(s) not in the retrieval pool (asserted, unverified)" } ], "integrity_cap": { "cap": 70, "reason": "1 cited source(s) not in the retrieval pool (asserted, unverified)" }, "polling": { "base_confidence": 99, "adjusted_confidence": 99, "consensus_dampening_pts": 0, "volatility_dampening_pts": 0, "volatility_band_pts": 6, "poll_size": 12, "consensus": { "authority_supported_pct": 100, "general_sources_supported_pct": 100, "strength": 1, "authority_vs_sources_gap_pct": 0, "echo_discount": 0.35, "dampening_pts": 0, "sample": 6 }, "volatility": { "heat": 0.41, "pressure": "elevated", "emotional_charge": 0.3, "news_churn": 0.58, "band_pts": 6, "dampening_pts": 0, "sample": 12 }, "note": "Information environment shows strong consensus (authority 100% / general sources 100% supported); remaining uncertainty is internal to the analysis, not the evidence base." }, "original_confidence": 99, "original_verdict": "false", "confidence_adjustments": [ { "reason": "integrity cap: 1 cited source(s) not in the retrieval pool (asserted, unverified)", "delta": -29, "before": 99, "after": 70 } ], "integrity_capped": true, "confidence_ratio": { "verdict": 99, "evidence": 90, "legend": "verdict confidence / how complete the evidence is", "verdict_inputs": { "stated": 99, "verdict_class_adjustment": 0, "load_bearing_coherence": 1, "corrected": false }, "evidence_inputs": { "sources": 8, "independent_origins": 7, "classes_present": 2, "class_counts": { "primary_record": 1, "scholarly": 7, "reportage": 0, "open_web": 0 }, "primary_found": true, "quasi_primary_found": false, "load_bearing": 1, "load_bearing_without_evidence": 0, "load_bearing_displaced": 0 }, "evidence_parts": { "origins": 40, "classes": 10, "primary": 20, "contact": 20 }, "weights": { "origins": "40 × min(1, (independent origins − 1) / 5)", "classes": "20 × classes present / 4 (primary record, scholarly, reportage, reference/open web)", "primary": "20 if an academic/government/legal source was retrieved; 10 if only reference-class; else 0", "contact": "20 × mean over load-bearing sub-claims (evidence spoke to it 1; displaced 0.5; mixed 0.75; unverifiable for lack of evidence 0)" }, "rule": "the denominator never feeds the numerator" }, "buoy_tick": 19450, "buoy_chain_hash": "bb6affa16fa35e2af9c94dbca220d7ecfd186e797b3e4df39252c83ca2502c74", "checks_remaining": 995, "tier": "pro" }